72 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. K's avatar

I know Bobby. He is the same warrior he always was. Those of you with "all or nothing" instincts (and I respect and understand that) hate the fact that the PREP act still exists at all with regard to spikeshots. But do not get confused with the PREP exclusion for a tiny group of people (those in quarantine) who WANT to take an (admittedly mixed blessing/curse) drug for the next six weeks. You could not have issued a more limited, patient-centric, non-threatening and non-coercive to anyone rule...and for those who want it it was the fastest way to get it in when it might make a difference. (We all know it might not, but this is a patient choice only PREP exclusion.) Everyone recoils when you say "Oh no, he invoked PREP" and that is understandable. But go read the actual action and you will see how limited it actually is both in time and effect. Do not confuse this minor blip with the bigger issues or throw the baby out with the bathwater.

In the horrible world of politics, one must often do things that are unpalatable because vast forces of money are arrayed against one. The whole vaccine issue is one of those. But RFK Jr has, often quite cleverly, circumvented these forces by doing end runs that in hindsight are even cleverer than I at first thought. When he was appointed my comment was "It is far easier to be the underdog fighting against the big bad wolf (I know, mixed metaphor) than to be the dog that caught the car. And that is where we are now. Whatever Bobby gets done will be more than you will see over the next 20 (or more) years so let us hope he lasts as long as he can stand it and does as much as he can. If it makes you feel better to have someone saying "all the right things" that can actually do nothing about any of them that is your right. But I am not in that camp...I prefer someone doing as many right things as are physically and politically possible. One man's opinion.

Madhava Setty, MD's avatar

"Whatever Bobby gets done will be more than you will see over the next 20 (or more) years so let us hope he lasts as long as he can stand it and does as much as he can."

I don't agree. Nearly everything he gets done can be overturned and/or ignored. In order for enduring change to occur public opinion must shift. He is far more potent outside of the system than within. Things would be different, of course, if he truly had executive power.

There has been a shift in public opinion. I see it in my practice. That is what the polling results show. I argue that this momentum is the result of what Bobby was able to do when he was running for office and speaking clearly and definitively.

Yes, the PREP act, as declared in this instance is extremely limited, yet still unnecessary. The threat of the Andes strain of Hanta is not a matter of national security. That is a stipulation which must be fulfilled before a declaration is justified. As I said, the antiviral addressed in this declaration is already available to doctors. The declaration removes the liability from damages that could occur from its use. The inevitable consequence is that it will be used more frequently than it should. Moreover, the declaration removes the requirement for informed consent. When is this ever necessary?

I don't see this latest action on his part as proof of bad intentions. Rather I worry that folks on our side will use it to discredit him. This is the time where we need to come together.

Dr. K's avatar

Your final point is correct which is why I penned my note. If people understood the inconsequence of this particular hanta action they would not use up so much energy despairing that "all is lost". And let us remember that RFK Jr. spent 10 years at CHD and swayed almost no opinions anywhere -- it was only by getting involved in the political process and getting this appointment that the needle even began to budge. Perhaps that is just right place/right time but the facts are still the facts. But you are right -- coming (really staying) together is vitally important -- one cannot be distracted by the inevitable noise, often planted by those inimical to the cause who pretend to be on one's side.

Roc Findlay's avatar

I know that people don't like to hear this but this fella praised Trump for OWS, sometimes you just have to admit you've been dudded.

Kathryn's avatar

Although Dr. Setty, S. Latypova et al make good arguments, your letter has a ring of truth in it. Anyone who has been involved in a governmental machine( whatever scale) would also realize this.

My experience as a planning and zoning board member for a village(7,000pop) demonstrated this.

We had to abide by the zoning codes, no matter the individual rationale of the cases brought before us. There was an appalling lack of civic understanding of governmental process. This was a stressful and unrewarding position to hold, albeit a good learning experience.

Your panoramic letter illuminates Kennedy’s position and has enforced my opinion for continued support of Robert Kennedy Jr.

Being Bonnie's avatar

I was the Planning Chair in a small, southern municipality for 7 years. I share your disappointment in the ordinary citizen's understanding of 'governmental practice', never mind actual laws pertaining to building and zoning. So...to expect most people being bludgeoned by the volume of noise and information these days to comprehend nuanced actions...is asking a lot!

I an very wishy washy at this point with regard to Secretary Kennedy. If only I could get that picture of him and Shmuley Boteach out of my head...

David White (Oz Dave)'s avatar

Yes, if Kennedy doesn’t approve certain things he doesn’t want approved, then he’s out; and someone else would then approve them anyway. While Kennedy is in there is hope for some degree of change, which of course takes time.

Josh Mitteldorf's avatar

I hope Bobby can hear this message from you. Sasha Latypova offered the same message from a more alienated perspective yesterday. https://sashalatypova.substack.com/p/bobby-kennedy-fakes-a-pandemic-in

We need your reasoned voice and Sasha's shrill voice and everything in between. The question remains: Does Bobby know something that we don't that convinces him he will be able to accomplish his goals within a deeply corrupt administration? Or is he just seduced by power, as so many good people have been?

Madhava Setty, MD's avatar

Thanks Josh. I did get some input from Sasha last week off line. We were unable to come together around the tone. My basic argument is that anything with a Kennedy label on it will get ignored and attacked by the establishment. He's proven that already. Any meager gains he might earn will be challenged, ignored or reversed in a couple of years.

Reform around vaccines will only endure if the public wants them. Once public opinion starts to shift (it already has) PSAs from these medical organizations will be regarded much differently. They will be seen as manipulation and/or coercion. He can be much more powerful as a private citizen unencumbered by political allegiances.

Josh Mitteldorf's avatar

I agree -- in the long run, it is public education that matters, and we're making great strides.

Christina Phillips's avatar

This: “At this moment your influence over public opinion is trammelled by your association with the current administration.”

Brian Roberts's avatar

This is sound advice. I agree. Return to your parish. Continue your real work. “If there’s a fire you’re trying to douse, you can’t put it out from inside the house”. Thomas Jefferson as rendered in the musical Hamilton 😊

Jilli Ray Goldman's avatar

I hope this message reaches Robert F. Kennedy Jr. directly. Staying in this administration would be a profound disappointment and a squandering of what could be a truly meaningful legacy. This moment in history calls for more.

Jeff Schreiber's avatar

Madhava

Thanks for writing this message which covers a very important topic, and no matter how hard anyone tries to push it under the rug, it’s not going away anytime soon. The way I see it, medical freedom is, like many other struggles, in the front line in the ongoing war between good and evil.

And from that perspective it feels like the good wolf is winning when you consider how compared to 2020 (not that long ago), the current wave of awareness and compassion is enormous and growing. And sometimes when we get discouraged, it feels like the bad wolf is still on top. The corrupt and greedy are pulling out their strongest weapons. Here we stand.

This year I needed to take a step back from much of the conversation. For me it can be so damned confusing. Especially when I understand how little of the bigger picture I can see. So I listen and learn - watch and wait, listening with my heart and allowing my feelings into my thoughts. I guess that’s what praying is all about.

I’ve heard Bobby say again and again that he is going into prayer every day - I have no reason to doubt it. And cannot imagine what challenges he’s facing daily. In 2020 I read James Douglass’s JFK and the Unspeakable - Why He Died and Why it Matters - and it’s helped me understand what Bobby must be going through. This world is a very fucked up place because evil cleaver people run many of the systems and it sure looks like they are running them to Hell. So I certainly hope that he’s taking ever single step as carefully as his uncle and father did. They managed to turn the tide away from what likely would have been the end of us all. And they did it without any peace movement or alternative media directing a new narrative. All they had was their love of God and the prayers of humanity.

And this my friends is what is going to protect and motivate us.

Being Bonnie's avatar

Well, that worked for awhile...

Vinu Arumugham #MAHA's avatar

The HHS Secretary position is an "once-in-a-lifetime" opportunity. I think he should stay there as long as he is allowed to and cause as much damage to the government's mass murder machines as he can.

Madhava Setty, MD's avatar

I agree that it is a once in a lifetime opportunity. However the changes he is allowed to make won't be permanent and the impact of them, if there is any, will be lost in the noise.

The reality is that he got to the position ahead of schedule. But once the public wakes up to the reality around vaccines they will demand change or refuse to comply. That's when a referendum can happen. I can envision a time when painting a sanguine picture of vaccines on the political stage will come with stiff blowback. Then it will be over for the vaccine cult in this country.

The question is whether there is something to be gained by resigning with principle rather than hanging on until he is impeached or replaced. I think there is. He was making significant inroads into the public psyche when he was campaigning on his own ticket and speaking as candidly as he could. His reticence (not his fault) has stalled the movement.

Vinu Arumugham #MAHA's avatar

You may be right. But there are some big changes/uncertainties coming (midterm elections). Cassidy is gone. With Kennedy as HHS Secretary, vaccines are always in the news. Once he resigns, they will all stop talking about vaccines. The problem needs to be confronted on all fronts. If he is able to release some information that can be used in lawsuits against Pharma, those will be irreversible effects. Complex problem. Difficult to say with certainty which approach is best. And none of us know what Kennedy is experiencing which obviously informs his decisions.

J.CROW'S® Lugol's Iodine's avatar

I met Robert 3 times when he was in New England during the early days of his campaign. I gave him a pocket Manjrushri on one occasion for my perception of his real interest in cutting through the bullshit with the sword of prajna. On another visit, I gave him a pocket Buddha. On the final cross with him I gave a Tibetan coin with the 8 auspicious symbols. When he failed to speak out against the genocide in Gaza I realized it was over. Whoever Robert was when he announced in Boston has faded and his essence has been absorbed into the continuing mass psychosis we are all experiencing.

Josh Mitteldorf's avatar

Rather than resign, Bobby might do some of the things that he fears would get him fired. First on my list would be ending the PREP Act emergency declaration for COVID. Second would be ending all funding for bioweapons research. Third would be new rules for what constitutes a "safe" vaccine. He could do all this, and probably get himself fired in the process, but he'd leave behind a barrier for a new HHS secretary trying to un-do all these rulings.

Madhava Setty, MD's avatar

Agreed. I would rather have him thrown out for acting on his principles than going through the motions for another two years.

Red-Pilled ER Nurse's avatar

I like the tactic in this idea Josh. Push the ticket by actually doing some of what is most needed.

If it does get him fired that will reveal what should be obvious… Trump used and abused Bobby and his supporters for his own purposes and never intended to let him change anything of consequence.

Dan's avatar

Only someone in your position can give us this point of view.

Excellent post again Dr. Setty.

Dana Ullman, MPH, CCH's avatar

I am sympathetic with your serious concerns here...but I cannot imagine that anyone other than RFK, Jr. can or will make as much progress on health and medical issues as RFK, Jr can, despite his severe limitations. I think that we all know that RFK's wings ARE being clipped...and we all know that many FINE pro-RFK scientists have resigned. I simply do not want RFK to be another causality of the present politics.

The bottomline is that I trust RFK, even though he has not been able to say or enact many of the policies we want from him. For instance, this NY TImes article highlights that RFK is funding a $50 million study to evaluate the overall health of vaccinated vs. unvaccinated people, with Martin Kulldroff, MD (of Harvard) leading the study.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/11/health/kennedy-vaccine-safety.html

Madhava Setty, MD's avatar

I agree with you Dana. However if any study has his fingerprints on it it will jettisoned as antivax misinformation, no matter who the authors are. Presenting doctors with evidence of vaccine harm or ineffectiveness goes nowhere unless it comes with the blessing of the NEJM or the AMA, etc.

If there is one thing he could do it would be to open source the massive trove of record level data the CDC is sitting on. Even if he could somehow do that the orthodoxy will not examine it or throw frivolous complaints at those who do. We are dealing with cult like mentality. The public has to see that they have been part of the cult too.

Anthony Zappia's avatar

RFK Jr lost all credibility with me when he backed Trump over glyphosate. That would have been the moment to resign. But he didn't. I agree with you that victory will ultimately be a grass-roots, bottom-up affair. Robert should have used this upon entering office. He should have gone around the country with a road-show using those Vaccine movies and building a ground-swell. He would have had millions of people behind him. These people could have been used to reverse the 1986 legislation.

Joanna's avatar

His resignation is the leverage we cannot afford to be without. Thank you Dr S. for this and for all you do.

Dr. Victoria Dubin Master's avatar

I disagree. There is still much to be done that no one else will do in office and I think you should at least finish this term and even continue if that is feasible when the time comes.

Vaccines and medications will always be there for those who want it but you are doing so much good that would never happen if you were not in this position. From food to air to water to holistic health care. Meds and vaccines will always be controlled to some degree and we know you are doing your best in that insane cabal environment, so keep on doing the good work you are put there to do and be the voice of truth and transparency.

God Bless You RFK jr.

Elizabeth Woodworth's avatar

I think this is an excellent letter, Madhava, with much persuasive power from the position you occupy in medical practice.

I think RFK Jr. will have mixed feelings about doing as you suggest. Much of what he has been achieving has been regarding the lifestyle and dietary habits in America, which are at the root of so much of the poor thinking in the country. People simply are not well, with poor nutrition and about 45% obesity.

I worked in government public health for 25 years in British Columbia, and changing consumer health behaviour was the most difficult thing -- which really never got accomplished while I was working.

It must be very difficult for RFK to endure the recent foreign behaviour of the US administration, but I doubt he will give up his current opportunity to influence public health policy -- beyond the unrelenting profit motivation and ploys of big Pharma.

Madhava Setty, MD's avatar

The point I wish to get across is that the majority of the one million doctors in this country have to see that they too have been bamboozled by the system. The problem is that if RFK Jr. points it out they are going to dig their heels in. They have been programmed to react that way. Very few of my medical colleagues have ever heard him speak. None have read "The Real Anthony Fauci". They actually believe that is just a bunch of his ideations thrown together to fool the gullible into ignoring "the science". They don't realize that there are thousands of citations from peer reviewed literature that support the message in that book.

These are earnest and hardworking people but when they hear the name "Kennedy" it's like they have been subconsciously hypnotized to cluck like chickens at a comedy show. I have never seen anything like it.

Deb Hawthorne's avatar

One thing I always bring up to the naysayers when I talk about Kennedy book on Fauci is that it MUST be true otherwise Fauci would have sued him immediately over slander and ruining his reputation. The fact Fauci did not touch it is pretty telling! Some food for thought for those who just won’t read that book. That book really opened my eyes! !

J in veritatis inquisitione's avatar

Anyone who would go against the official health narrative would certainly receive the same disapproval from the good doctors. Kennedy or not.

Elizabeth Woodworth's avatar

I absolutely agree. Medicine's strong appeal to itself and to the public is its cohesive conservatism.

I was asked to review the latest book by James W. Douglass, "Martyrs to the Unspeakable: The assassinations of JFK, Malcolm, Martin, and RFK," one of the most thoroughly researched books I have ever read. My review is on amazon.com.

As older people know, the Kennedy's have been anathema to the deep state/establishment since the 60s. I don't know how the grassroots medical doctors are going to be persuaded to change their opinion, unless it's because of the persistence of big Pharma attempts to create more pandemics such as hantavirus and now Ebola.

RFK said in Milan during the pandemic that 1/3 of the people are awake, 1/3 will never wake up, and it's the third in the middle that have a chance of understanding the truth. Focussing on them might be the solution… I've been part of the Google group established by Harvey Risch and Peter McCullough during the pandemic, and that might be a logical starting point.

Media Luna's avatar

I’ve always sensed that RFK.jr would have been more effective working outside the system.

I didn’t think that running for president was the path he should have taken because it would dilute his focus on health freedom.

When he shifted and joined the Trump group, I thought maybe that was the opportunity to keep that focus.

But I can see what Dr. Madhava Setty describes as he experiences it from within the medical profession. Doctors and many non medical people (family and friends) dig their heels and would never be dissuaded by any directive or suggestion coming from a RFK-headed HHS because his association with the Trump administration.

They just place their hands on their ears and scream 😱 as children who do not want to hear.

Yes, victory will ultimately be a bottom-up affair and the battle must continue even if the results we expect do not happen in our lifetimes.

As Jeff Schreiber wrote in another comment here: “So I listen and learn - watch and wait, listening with my heart and allowing my feelings into my thoughts. I guess that’s what praying is all about.”

Thank you, Madhava for your carefully considered and eloquent words.