206 Comments
author
Jun 8, 2023·edited Jun 10, 2023Pinned

I am encouraged to see so many thoughtful and informed comments on this post. Though these topics can be triggering for many, the exchanges in the comments have been, with only a few exceptions, respectful.

Though the world's attention has been captured by all things Covid for the last three years, the uncertainties about what happened on 9/11 are still relevant. IMO, it is easier to see the lies in the official narrative about that event. 9/11 gives us the proof that corporate media--all corporate media--will bend to the will of their masters, whomever they are.

The journalists that reported on that event were not being coerced. They were being manipulated at a deep level, much like those who accepted their content prima facie.

I believe that most thought they were doing a good job. It's a challenge to pull someone out of their world view, especially those who pride themselves on being informed. It's going to take more than information and data. It's going to take style, tone and the right attitude for the right person.

That being said, I would like to set the record straight here. I did not expect to change the minds of my classmates with a single conversation. I wanted to "plant the seeds" with my classmates as @Lundy Bancroft suggested.

Neither was I expecting to change the minds of readers with a single post. This is a subject that deserves time and deep investigation.

With that said, the greatest trove of accurate information around 9/11 has been at Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth:

https://www.ae911truth.org

I highly suggest using that resource (and the ones given below) if you happen to have the rare opportunity to engage someone around this topic.

My friend, Richard Gage, former CEO of AE911Truth put together three webinars that were designed to educate architects about what happened on that day and why the official explanation skirts the basic questions that we assumed were answered. These presentations are technical but wonderfully done:

https://richardgage911.org/in-depth-webinars/

Incidentally, Richard Gage, the founder and front-man for AE911Truth for more than a decade, was asked to step down two years ago because he spoke "off topic". He had expressed criticism around the pandemic response. In my mind, these two engineered catastrophes are intimately conjoined, and he was right to speak out when he did.

He has since amassed a great deal of accurate, technical information on his own website:

https://richardgage911.org

Planting seeds is our job right now. I think that Covid has given us an opportunity to shatter the illusions so many hold. It's easy to get impatient, but seeds take time to mature into trees.

Expand full comment
Jun 12, 2023Liked by Madhava Setty

It was about a dozen years ago that I started to learn the truth regarding 9/11. I’m open to anything because I don’t trust the powers that be. If they lied about the JFK assassination and Vietnam, why should this be any different?

So I began showing the evidence and counter points to the many academics that I worked with in my textbook business and was so surprised how almost none of them were able to see what was to me, a college dropout, quite clear and obvious. One day I showed a video of the demolition of Building 7 to a Criminal Justice professor at a local community college here in NJ. As a former police investigator he took one look at it and said to me that it was no doubt a demolition. I realized at that moment that he was trained to look at things critically, something so few who have passed through the halls of higher learning are able to do. Our education system is really more of place that produces followers than one training thinkers. Even at places like MIT or Harvard.

Expand full comment
Jun 9, 2023Liked by Madhava Setty

Thank you for these helpful links. Understanding 9/11 is the key to unlocking the understanding of the extent of evil and control the dark government and media has over us.

Expand full comment

When people questioned my Covid attitude my usual response was they lost me on 9/11 and will never get me back! You liked my comment and so checked out your stack. Treasure trove. Thanks

Expand full comment

I'm coming to your blog fairly late for this post, and I'll admit that I cringed through the garden-party scene (but I kept reading).

9/11/01 was a busy work day for me at 2 different sites, supervising residents in the morning.

I heard that a plane had hit the WTC on the kitchen radio as I got my coffee, then there were two, and all day there were the same scenes on TVs everywhere. You know them.

I met with my Buddhist practice group that night and we practiced Tonglin (first time) for those in the rubbble. This is a meditation where one accepts the suffering of others and sends them peace and support.

The next morning I got up extra early and went to go donate (O+) blood before dawn. As I came out a TV reporter tried to get the story that lines were too long, but I had gotten right in to donate, I said. (Scowl from reporter.)

It was the "new Pearl Harbor", the (FDR arrangement) story of which I knew well, but I never stopped to wonder if it was "an inside job". It was Too BIG.

But I was wrong. The Big Lie works better, because nobody consideres that it COULD be a big-lie...

Fairly soon I was introduced to weird stories on new websties like Letsrolll911 and 911Physics. It clearly seemed impossible for WTC-7 to collapse at 5:20 PM as the evening news was already showing, except that BBC news announced it had fallen, while it stood in the window behind the announcer. ("Lucky") Larry Silverstein, who had recently purchased the WTC (including alll the condemned asbestos in it) said in an interview that "they decided to 'pull' it", meaning a controlled demolition, which takes months to set-up. He was "lucky" tohave gotten quadruple inddemnity against terrorist attacks. And so on...

There are possibilities for what happened that day, which respect the laws of physics, and it is impossible to be certain, because all evidence was quickly scooped up and removed from the crime scene, made into rebar in India, for instance.

I remain particularly intrigued by the pools of molten steel persisting for a month under the rubble of the twin towers... Not jet fuel.

We have somewhat similar educational backgrounds.. I started in E.E. at UT Austin in 1976, working my way through from the next summer forward, in a hospital kitchen at first...

I changed majors after 2 years, and eventually graduated with 225 hours, including 4 semesters of physics after 6 years of living in co-ops and avoiding debts.

I got into med school at UT Houston, my first choice. (Then I got into debt, but less than most.)

Expand full comment
author

The persistence of molten material and fires for three months is another indication that this was not a gravitational collapse. Even CNN reported that fires at ground zero were finally extinguished three months later despite total immersion under millions of gallons of water. Fires cannot burn without a source of oxygen. This means that the oxygen was part of an accelerant that was ubiquitous. Notably, thermite and its variations include O2 as Ferrous Oxide.

https://edition.cnn.com/2001/US/12/20/rec.athome.facts/index.html

Expand full comment

There was evidence of thermite. I remember seeing that analysis of debris back in the day, however the total energy contained in molten steel to keep it molten for over a month may have been more than could have been practically obtained through that mechanism alone.

There are other intriguing theories about where that much energy might have come from, while still being consistent with what was observed.

Expand full comment
deletedOct 20, 2023·edited Oct 20, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

A small nuclear warhead in the basement, detonated after removal of the gold, would have inductively heated the steel within the core of the towers, also. It is an intriguing theory.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

I have to believe that planting the seeds matters, because otherwise I'd feel too discouraged. I think people get a lot of security from believing that there are good people in charge and that "they" just wouldn't do certain things. And I think those same people sometimes can, over time, let go of that myth and realize that the unethical and the power-mad (who are often the same people) tend to rise to the top -- and that our social and legal structures actually encourage that rather than obstructing it. For some people it can literally take five years (or whatever) to gradually absorb the information and adapt to it. So I believe that you're accomplishing more than you know. And to me it's significant that you had at least one person there honestly grappling with what you were revealing to them. These little cracks that we make in the wall spread over time.

Expand full comment

Dear Mr Bancroft. Your name immediately rang a bell! I want to take this opportunity to thank you. Your books on emotional abuse are extremely important - I have recommended them to so many! Know that you had a part in saving this mom and her children from a lifetime of trauma. I'm pleased, but not surprised that you are speaking up against the madness in our society. Once you know the abuser's tool box, it's not hard to recognise that we're in an abusive relationship with our so called leaders. One of the hardest things for a victim of abuse is to face the reality of the situation and realise that there will be no change for the better. Many still need to wake up to this, and it's painful to watch their willing blindness. But, like you said, we have to keep showing them the truth. Thank you again for your great contribution to society.

Expand full comment

Totally agree Lundy. The seeds are sprouting. I’m hearing conversion stories weekly now.

Expand full comment

"Doug broke the silence. “I thought they have been proven to be safe and effective.”"

No technical college graduate should ever utter these words. This is an indication of a pernicious form of educational failure in which a mind is taught to be closed outside of a command line controlled by a post-graduate media.

Expand full comment

Here we are in June of 2023. Anyone who believes the jabs are safe and effective, God help them, they'll believe anything.

Expand full comment

My favourite is when the MORE-ONS insisted I get injected and I said -- I probably will .. once I get to have a look at the long term safety studies.

That always left them speechless (f789ing MORE-ONS)

Expand full comment

I said exactly that when my doctor was encouraging me to get the shot during an annual physical. He simply nodded his head and moved on to a different topic.

Expand full comment

This is the only argument I ever gave my daughter permission to use when it seemed likely that peer pressure might become a topic at school. I told her no one can argue with you if you say this is your reason. She is strong and getting stronger, but she is still a child and I wanted her to feel confident in any conversation.

Expand full comment

There was one time that a CovIDIOT would not accept that bit of logic ...

This CovIDIOT has high blood pressure and is on meds ... so I said ... let's say a vaccine that was developed in less than a year was made available to you -- emergency use authorization -- promised to be safe and effective at ending your high BP ... surely you would be willing o take it.

He refused to answer.

This raises the age old question ... should one cast pearls among swine

Expand full comment

I'm less concerned about what he believes than why. "I thought somebody proved" is never good epistemology for a life or death decision.

Expand full comment
author

That's exactly the point. We have devolved into a society that is screaming over facts that no one can confirm with certainty. The only way through this is to critique how we arrive at our positions.

Expand full comment
Jun 7, 2023Liked by Madhava Setty

This was fascinating to read. Kudos to you for speaking so plainly about all of this to your classmates! Just four or five years ago, if anyone had spoken to me about 9/11 the way you did in this post, my mind would have shut down. My response would have been similar to that of your classmates. It frustrates me that it has taken so long for my eyes to open!

The most disappointing thing about the conversations you describe is the scripted nature of the responses by these highly intelligent people, now compromised by the conditioning they have received via our government agencies and media. Thank you for speaking up and for letting us all know how it went.

Expand full comment

Spot on with your “scripted responses” comment!

Expand full comment

Yes. They are possessed by ideas. They recite thought-terminating cliches.

Expand full comment

And yet, Fran, you are the perfect person to share about your delay in grasping that our world is stuck in a sticky web of control. That's because there are so many just like you so you can be like an AA sponsor supporting newbies. As a health nut, my awakening happened when I read Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, so long ago that I have no credibility with friends and family who still believe the veneer, I'm just the eccentric one.

Expand full comment

You make an excellent point—I hope so! But I’ve been skeptical about health matters for so long (haven’t been to a doctor for ten years—and before that, I only let them do labs, really) that people already think I’m pretty odd. The skepticism got worse for me when, in March of 2020, I started a new job with a case of covid. I shook 15 hands and sat in cramped conference rooms with coworkers for two of my first four days with covid. Not one of these people became infected or seemed to personally know anyone who became infected. Three weeks went by before I understood what I had. It then occurred to me that covid could not be as infectious as it was reputed to be, and I realized something was off. As a New Yorker who lived through 9/11, I’m a bit ashamed that my skepticism did not extend further, sooner! But I appreciate your comment and am doing my best to pass along what I know whenever I see an opportunity to do so. Will definitely read Silent Spring, since my own family was profoundly affected by pesticides.

Expand full comment

As they say, The Truth Will Out! We each have our own pace.

I wonder if Santa Claus was invented to get children in the habit of believing far fetched ideas that adults conspire to prop up-- because they love us....

That's one of the best C Theories ever:

A jolly elf who tirelessly visits all the believers on Earth in ONE NIGHT

Even houses with no CHIMNEYS

In a sleigh that FLIES

The presents all FIT in the SLEIGH

Santa READS our letters

Santa's SURVEILLANCE NETWORK knows who's been naughty and nice

Santa cares about people but GIVES POOR CHILDREN WORSE PRESENTS than rich kids

And let's not forget the Tooth Fairie and the Easter Bunny.

Expand full comment

Food for thought!! That surveillance network sure did cause me some stress as a child. I remember many an hour spent worrying about having to explain the lump of coal in my stocking to my family on Christmas morning.

Expand full comment

My mind DID shut down. But I kept thinking and questioning my reactions. Then my mind changed. Our brains developed in the natural process of evolution in a natural way, not in a technological or man-made setting. The collapse of the tower was outside of nature. When seeing a modern building collapse it is difficult to assess and the mind has to look several times. The mind can "tell the truth" but it cannot do so in a totally man-made artificial technology environment without returning several times to the situation and re-thinking repeatedly. It is abstract thinking, taking place outside of the natural world.

Expand full comment

Good for you for having an open mind. It certainly took me a long time to open mine.

Expand full comment

Right? I will always remember the day my new conspiracy theorist friend dropped this bomb on me as we drove to a corona protest together. I was in shock, but I was prepared to entertain the idea. Oh boy. And I had vehemently protested the Patriot Act and the WMD war. So odd that I could see through the pretense but didn't bother to question our very first assumption of terrorism. Lessons learned!

Expand full comment

Bless your heart for being willing to speak up. There really is no other option, but many have remained silent.

I am still dealing with people who won't speak to me, including frriends from many decades, but some are coming back slowly.

Expand full comment

I see the symmetry whilst it fell and finding bone fragments on the top of surrounding buildings could only mean explosions obliterated and sent debris out not down. My husband was there and saw the second tower fall as he left the Fulton Street subway. He is still so triggered by these images. Even today one of the many people he helped get home that day contacted him to let him know her son did a report on Michael and the heroic things he did that day. Its not "Never Forget" it's "Can't Forget" for him and for those who witnessed the US's attack on itself.

Expand full comment

A thank you to Michael for helping as best he could on that day.

Expand full comment
Jun 7, 2023·edited Jun 7, 2023Liked by Madhava Setty

Really well written. I was on the edge of my seat rooting for truth -- via you -- to penetrate.

The sentence that struck me the most was “the common factor on both of these outrageous ‘conspiracy theories’ was me.” To me, that evokes so well the loneliness of having looked into -- really researched -- something clearly dubious and questionable, only to be left with sadness upon realizing that a lot of people won't even consider for a minute that there might be anything amiss with mainstream narratives, and would rather change their previously high esteem of you than rethink their own beliefs.

Expand full comment

Today’s Coffee and Covid has a pretty convincing theory that the alien thing may be a scam that will be used to panic people before the elections—more mass mail-in ballots I guess.

Expand full comment

It may also be a limited hangout to scam China & Russia by hinting that we may have developed an advanced weapon(s) from the discovery…

Expand full comment

Yes. Dr. Steven Greer has been screaming about this for years to any who would listen!

Expand full comment

I have been following you on Covid issues, but I was surprised and pleased to see that you have an interest in 9/11 as well, and that one of my videos "spoke" to you! If any of your readers want to see more of where the "North Tower Exploding" video came from, go to http://911speakout.org.

(Speaking out fearlessly is obviously something else we have in common ... also South India, where I taught at Kodaikanal International School for several years.)

Expand full comment
author

Thanks David. 9/11 is the bedrock for me. This is the ground from which we construct a different understanding of reality where authority, "trusted" media and official commissions have no more weight than anyone else.

I honestly am perplexed by those who have been able to see through the 9/11 story but remain content to swallow the Covid narrative.

Six years ago when I became aware of WTC7, I tried my best to defend the official explanations against my skepticism. As a reality check I went to some of my engineering colleagues, asking them to talk me out of my conspiratorial notions. We haggled about how to weigh the evidence. It was your North Tower video that affirmed my understanding and sent them back to their bubbles.

Was always interested in your motivations to make the video. Looking forward to learning about the origins of this content. Thank you for weighing in here sir.

Expand full comment
Jun 8, 2023·edited Jun 8, 2023Liked by Madhava Setty

When people ask how I got into 9/11 I say it dates back to the early 1980's when I was involved with the Sanctuary Movement, sheltering Salvadoran refugees fleeing the death squads we had unleashed upon them. That broke the back of the "American Exceptionalism" myth for me and allowed logic to prevail in the case of 9/11 without the psychological barriers. The vast majority of my colleagues involved in 9/11 research have been able to see through the Covid Vax scam as well.

As for the "North Tower Exploding" video, and also for WTC 7, I tell people you don't need a scientist or engineer to tell you it's all wrong. You can see it with your own eyes. What we are doing is just proving you're not crazy!

Expand full comment

That is the key here. Nobody wants to try to read a long paper full of words they cannot comprehend; Richard Feynman has written that any, or most, science findings should resonate for ordinary persons as well. Or else it was that any science finding should be capable of being explained in simple words. This I believe is really profound. I would like to find some more to read like this.

Expand full comment

The very last sentence in your discussion says it all.

I was in a room full of architects and engineers when we all saw the second tower fall, and everyone had a gut feeling that 'something was wrong with this picture'. No one stated any theories, but most of them thought what they were seeing was impossible, but there it was.

I worked at the Pentagon for a Summer in the late '80's architecturally surveying the entire 3rd floor with a team of Architects for eventual renovation planning. Having worked there and having lived in the DC area for over twenty years, I also knew it was impossible for a jet liner to approach the first floor of the Pentagon, at flying speed, and hit that level dead on.....impossible. Just as impossible as the narrative we've been fed all these years. The biggest crime in America, against America, by Americans probably.

Thank you Madhava Setty for your tenacious battle for truth, transparency and Disclosure. God willing the entire world gets to see Steven Greer's presentation on Disclosure at 2:00pm, June 12th at the National Press Club. Everyone should tell their Congressional Districts about this event.

Expand full comment

This is exactly the way most physicians felt when Covid emerged. Anyone with a basic understanding of molecular biology, virology, immunology and epidemiology - as ALL physicians MUST have - understood there were as many deficiencies in the Covid narrative as there were in the Building 7 narrative.

Many refused to speak out, but ALL understood. Very disillusioning to see my colleagues act just as physicians did in 1930s Germany.

https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/history/articles/fernandes-doctors-who-became-nazis?s=09

Expand full comment

The whole Scamdemic thing (British researcher Richard D Hall coined this) has me perplexed about health care professionals seemingly polarized opinions. I'm like you, they are well educated for many years. How can they not know what is going on? I did from day one, and I'm not in the health care industry. I am a degreed Architect and I was highly suspect about all of it and my investigations and open mind proved out. Just as I did not quite believe the impossible images I viewed on the day of 911 with my fellow Architects and Engineers. Some people just want to wallow in their own lost paradigm, while others refuse to believe that people in power could ever conceive of doing harm to the public. But, now, it is All out in the open for All to see....if they entertain the idea of critical thinking.

Expand full comment

Two cliches seem appropriate.

"It's easy to fool someone but impossoble to convince them they have been fooled"

"Hard to convince someone whose salary depends on believing otherwise."

Expand full comment

These point directly at two of humanity’s greatest weaknesses - ego and greed. The controllers who weave the web of deception know this well and utilize it to the max.

Expand full comment

That says it all amigo

Expand full comment

I’m a doctor but I disagree - they did not know. They are not taught to question anything. But now they know :)

Expand full comment

Yet they STILL continue to vaccinate kids and pregnant women, and Rx Remdesivir.

Expand full comment

they know, they don't know; they know, they don't know; they know, they don't know...

Expand full comment

I had a very curious experience. I was just about the ONLY 'homeless' (bad term) person with a good education. I was in Miami, having been sleeping in public areas (or trespassing in intelligently selected private ones) and shortly into the COVID episode I found a big thick epidemiology textbook. Well, that might be helpful, right? The whole thing was just gobbelty-gook. It was like the book had nothing in it. There was only one or two sentences that could connect to a pandemic, e.g. COVID. The book just seemed to me to be devoid of content. When I hear someone is an "epidemiologist" I always wonder if they know more than that stupid book did. Public health or nursing textbooks since the eighties are filled with nonsense. All make up stuff. Nothing there. This is our society. I have a little money now (trickling in from a property sale) but I just do not like money things. I cannot spend it or invest it worth a damn. I am getting a slightly terrified feeling, thinking what if I just sit in this motel room until it happens once again. Which would be when money runs out again (I am still a year plus, from that event but it is getting to be a worry). Please read my Substick newsletters referrably from the beginning (before I was famous). At the start, I felt had nothing to lose. Medium actually had just kicked me off for asking whether a person was a male or a female

Expand full comment

when I posted, I saw "7 hours ago." That is wrong. It took awhile to write, okay. But not seven hours.

Expand full comment

The perpetrators are NOT American, they may have the nationality and a number of residences in the US but have no allegiance to anyone and to anywhere but to themselves. They are globalists and masons.

Expand full comment

I agree. A real American would never do such a thing

Expand full comment
Jun 7, 2023Liked by Madhava Setty

The truth is not convenient. A real friend or MIT bro will dig in and do their own research. Smart in biz silo, does not always carry . You rocked em Madhava. Nice. Talk to Kirsch, another MIT kid. Great day Madhava! Scott

Expand full comment

I usually start with building 7 - it *literally* fell at -9.8m/s^2.

Freefall acceleration means ALL of the gravitational potential energy is being converted to kinetic energy of motion; NONE of this energy is available to do any crushing, pulverizing etc.

Expand full comment
author

Yes. Building 7 is the thread that yearns to be yanked. One of my classmates was not aware of its demise

Expand full comment

Don’t forget about the reporter who announced on BBCTV that #7 had fallen while she was standing in front of a still-standing #7.

Expand full comment

Which speaks to the overwhelming power of the media and "crowds" to influence thinking. There are MANY physicians who are unaware Officer suppressed millions of pages of damning internal documents until a court compelled release at about 50k pages per month. And that they KNEW exactly how harful and ineffective these experimental gene therapy products are.

https://lawyersforjusticeireland.wordpress.com/2022/03/20/release-of-pfizer-documents/

Expand full comment

Always better to come out as a conspiracy theorist rather than coming out with myocarditis.

Expand full comment

We're on a similar journey. Thanks for the transparency about communication; it was helpful.

Whatever the truth is, we have to be able to have intelligent debates without name calling. Media, including alt media, has done a great job of amplifying alot of 9/11 nonsense and limited hangouts. 9/11 was a CRIME but was not investigated as such. And what there was has been memory holed. But I believe the truth is available for those with eyes to see.

They got away with an incomplete 9/11 analysis at best. I believe this led to their knowing they could get away with a harmful covid agenda. AIDS was a factor too. Plus with JFK and the U.S.S. Liberty. Everyone wants to 'get back to normal' after trauma. But we need smart people like you to continue to push for truth and accountability.

Thank you for your bravery and applying your gifts!

Expand full comment
Jun 7, 2023Liked by Madhava Setty

Wow! Refreshing honesty, bravery and truth telling. The case you make is compelling to me. It’s astounding how others shut off. You got farther than I was expecting! Your example helps. Mucho thanks.

Expand full comment
author

Thanks for chiming in Doug

Expand full comment

I like how all your friends went to MIT to become wine experts.

Expand full comment
Jun 8, 2023Liked by Madhava Setty

You know the premise of the book “Blink”? That your first instinct is usually correct? My late Indian engineer father who stood first in high school and university and was educated at the finest institutions around the world, said to me, muttering under his breath, as we watched the towers fall on TV: “Those buildings came down too fast.”

We moved on and along with the mainstream narrative, until 2006 when I happened upon “Loose Change” on YouTube. I told my dad about it and he immediately believed this was something more sinister. My beautiful left-brained genius dad - deemed a brilliant visionary and intellectual by everyone who knew him - just KNEW it was bullshit. He wasn’t prone to conspiracies or religion or spirituality or any of that - but he knew and understood and FELT the truth.

Thank you for sharing this and for actually speaking up. I’m a doctor who gave up a while ago…

Expand full comment

That’s a great vignette, could be a pivotal opening scene in a movie--thanks!

Expand full comment